Auto insurance Recent Posts

The best insurance companies of 2024 for male drivers in Ontario

Shopping for car insurance as a male driver living in Ontario? Your search ends here. You might have wondered who the best insurance company is for male drivers, and we’re here to tell you that the answer really depends! 

Mitch crafts a list of the best insurance companies for specific demographics each year to help give our customers an idea of how the different companies we partner with “square up.” Although we only looked at cost comparisons in our list, note that there’s much more that goes into an insurance company besides its price. Check out our post on the 2024 best auto insurance companies in Ontario for additional information.  

Our key findings

  • SGI had the best insurance rates for male drivers, but CAA was a close contender. SGI’s average rate for our male drivers was around 1.5% lower than CAA’s. 
  • Although SGI had the best average rate for our male drivers, Zenith, CAA, and Commonwell each had the best rates for one of our driver profiles.  
  • The best high-risk market insurer for our male drivers was Coachman, with Pafco coming in at a close second.  

Rankings

Auto insurance is divided into two different markets: standard and high-risk. Standard is pretty much anyone with a decent/semi-clean insurance record, and high-risk is for those who have spotty driving records or have a history of cancellation due to non-payment. The latter often sells their plans for higher premiums, so we’ve divided our comparisons into regular and high-risk to make things fairer.  

Table 1. Best regular market insurers for male drivers in 2024 

  1. SGI 
  1. CAA 
  1. Zenith 
  1. Commonwell 
  1. Intact 
  1. Wawanesa 
  1. Aviva 
  1. Economical 
  1. Pembridge 
  1. Travelers 

Table 2. Best high-risk market insurers for male drivers in 2024 

  1. Coachman 
  1. Pafco 
  1. JEVCO 
  1. Echelon 

Meet our drivers

To give you an idea of the kind of rates that men in the province might expect from the various insurance companies that exist, we’ve created our own list of eight fictional male driver profiles. Each driver varies by their driving record, age, location, vehicle, etc., with the only constant being that they’re all male. We also kept coverage, policy limits, discounts, and deductibles the same to ensure that our final prices wouldn’t be influenced by these.  

Here are our drivers: 

  • Don, 21, single, Caledon (L7C), clean record
    • Drives a 2013 ACURA TL SH-AWD
  • Asher, 39, married, Mississauga (L5B), following too close in 2021
    • Drives a 2019 FORD RANGER XL
  • Raphael, 51, single, Guelph (N1H), clean record
    • Drives a 2016 HONDA ACCORD SPORT
  • Westley, 40, married, Waterloo (N2J), speeding tickets in 2021 and 2022
    • Drives a 2019 VOLKSWAGEN BEETLE DUNE HATCHBACK FWD
  • Beau, 32, married, Woodstock (N4S), speeding ticket in 2023
    • Drives a 2022 NISSAN PATHFINDER SL 4WD
  • Arnaud, 25, single, Orangeville (L9W), clean record
    • Drives a 2020 BMW 2 SRIES 230i xDRIVE COUPE AWD
  • Edouard, 42, married, Hamilton (L8E), careless driving in 2022, at-fault claim in 2023 
    • Drives a 2017 JEEP WRANGLER UNLIMITED SAHARA 4WD 
  • Noah, 28, single, Kitchener (N2A), two speeding tickets in 2021, at-fault claim in 2024 
    • Drives a 2019 AUDI A3 2.0T QUATTRO 

Quote comparisons

 
Table 1. Insurance rates compared for males in Ontario1
Company Don Asher Raphael Westley Beau Arnaud Reg Avg. Edouard Noah High Risk Avg.
Aviva $8,394 $2,393 $1,712 $2,243 $3,490 $5,673 $3,984
CAA $6,965 $2,087 $1,563 $1,750 $2,585 $4,167 $3,186
Commonwell $7,575 $2,569 $1,761 $1,991 $2,163 $3,595 $4,107
Economical $10,029 $3,165 $1,986 $2,113 $3,377 $3,974 $3,301
Intact $5,373 $2,555 $2,281 $2,287 $2,811 $4,504 $3,267
Pembridge $6,150 $2,884 $2,601 $3,084 $4,895 $6,142 $4,292
SGI $5,071 $2,898 $2,081 $2,066 $2,810 $3,991 $3,152
Travelers $8,040 $6,156 $3,708 $3,900 $4,716 $4,176 $3,275
Wawanesa $7,385 $2,252 $1,912 $2,935 $4,304 $3,818 $5,116
Zenith $5,003 $2,839 $1,907 $2,016 $3,729 $4,110 $3,767
Coachman $8,230 $8,650 $8,440
Echelon $10,791 $9,673 $10,232
JEVCO $8,394 $10,023 $9,208
Pafco $10,853 $7,218 $9,035
1Data source: Mitch auto insurance quoter

These rates may be different every year

If you’ve checked out our list of last year’s best insurance companies for male drivers, you might have noticed our rankings are somewhat different. This is partly because we’ve used different driver profiles than previously (and therefore produced different results), but it’s also because rates change over time. No one insurance company will remain the best option for any one demographic permanently. As time goes on, claim costs will fluctuate and insurers will have to either lower or heighten their premiums to keep their pool of payout money adequate.  

If one insurer is “top dog” for a specific demographic and winning a lot of new customers, chances are another company will follow suit to attract more business. This can also result in insurance companies having a different place on the ranking year-over-year.  

Get the best insurance rates with Mitch

While we can’t tell you who exactly is the best insurance company for male drivers, we can work with you personally to understand your needs and the kind of coverage you need. Plus, with our access, we’ll help to find you the best price. We work with over 70 of the leading insurance companies in Canada, meaning there’s plenty of options for us to search from to find you a great solution.  

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

Young man driving in a convertible sports car.
Driving Tesla down a tunnel.

Best car insurance companies for Tesla drivers in 2024

Teslas are considered the pinnacle of electric vehicle innovation, merging sleek design with cutting-edge technology. They’re known for many advanced features, from long-range capabilities to impressive acceleration, but they’re also a symbol of eco-friendly luxury in the auto world. 

For Tesla drivers, the importance of selecting an insurance company that understands the value and unique needs of electric vehicles cannot be overstated. But which insurance companies are the best for Tesla drivers in 2024? 

Key findings

  • For all the most common Tesla models (3, S, X, and Y), CAA offered the lowest auto insurance rates. 
  • The Tesla Model X had the highest rates with every insurance company. 
  • Pembridge had the highest rates for every Tesla model, apart from Zenith’s pricing for the Tesla Model X. 

How do different auto insurance companies price insurance for Teslas?

Every insurer is unique and charges different prices for coverage depending on their database of statistics and what they have experienced when it comes to losses involving Teslas.  

To show how different auto insurers price coverage for 2023 Tesla Models 3, S, X, and Y, we ran insurance quotes for a fictional 35-year-old married male who lives in CITY, has a clean driving record and drives approximately 13,000 km a year. 

 
Table 1. Price comparisons for Tesla insurance companies1
Insurance Company Tesla Model 3 Tesla Model S Tesla Model X Tesla Model Y
Aviva $3,837 $6,048 $7,115 $4,711
CAA $3,071 $3,609 $4,099 $3,204
Commonwell $3,974 $4,450 $5,007 $3,892
Intact $3,345 $5,017 $6,047 $4,308
Pembridge $6,932 $10,916 $11,131 $8,661
SGI Canada $3,606 $4,305 $4,958 $3,860
Travelers $3,312 $3,660 $4,620 $3,336
Wawanesa $4,588 $6,108 $7,635 $5,056
Zenith $4,976 $7,825 $17,800 $4,649
1Data source: Mitch auto insurance quoter

Some companies may also offer discounts and savings for Teslas. Companies also offer battery coverage (which can hike costs and wasn’t included in our quotes), and so on.  

Why are insurance rates for Teslas more expensive?

Teslas tend to be more expensive to insure than gas-powered cars because of their value and repair costs. The price of Teslas may start coming down to be more affordable in the future, but they’re currently still considered luxury vehicles. 

Below are the average price ranges for Teslas, which may give you a better idea as to why these vehicles typically cost more to insure:  

  • Tesla Model 3: $40,000-$55,000 
  • Tesla Model S: $75,000-$90,000 
  • Tesla Model X: $80,000-$90,000 
  • Tesla Model Y: $44,000-$52,000 
Tesla Model X on the road.
Photo by Tesla

Tesla prices vary depending on the trim and options. As insurance premiums usually factor in replacement cost, the more expensive the trim and the more features your car has, the likelier your insurance costs are to go up. Working with a broker to help you find the best insurance company for your Tesla is essential in helping manage your budget.  

How will auto insurance rates for Teslas change over time?

From an outsider’s perspective, Teslas and similar electric vehicles are no different than traditional gas-powered cars apart from the fuel source. Why should the insurance be any different?  

Well, one feature Teslas are rolling out and improving with each passing year is autonomous driving. Current autonomous features include forward collision warning and mitigation, autopilot with lane-keeping assist, etc. Full self-driving capabilities may be on the horizon, however, and with autonomous driving comes the possibility of minimum auto insurance requirements or built-in insurance costs.  

Could electric vehicles cause more dangerous collisions?

When it comes to Teslas, it’s important to think about their weight. Electric cars tend to be heavier than traditional gas ones, which can make accidents more serious, especially when they involve lighter vehicles. Take Tesla’s Cybertruck, for instance, which weighs about 7,000 pounds (about the weight of an elephant), with around 30% of that being its batteries alone. If you’re in a collision while driving a Tesla, you might be safer than the other vehicle involved, particularly if it’s not an electric one. In such cases, the other vehicle could sustain serious damage and the people inside could suffer severe injuries. 

Get coverage for your Tesla from Mitch Insurance

Mitch works with some of the best Tesla insurance companies in Ontario. If you’re looking for great protection for your Tesla at an affordable price, give us a call and get a free insurance quote today.  

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

Two women parked in their car.

The best insurance companies of 2024 for female drivers in Ontario 

In 2024, everything from rent to groceries is pricier, putting a strain on finances. Female drivers can save money by picking the right car insurance in Ontario. But with so many options, who’s the top choice for them? 

We’ve compared various female driver profiles among some popular insurers we partner with. Remember, while we looked at costs, there’s more to an insurance company than just price. When shopping for auto insurance, other factors matter too. Check out our post on the 2024 best auto insurance companies in Ontario for additional information.  

Our key findings

  • We found that the insurer with the lowest rates for all our female drivers, on average, was Commonwell. Commonwell was about 12% less expensive than the runner-up, CAA.  
  • We found the most affordable insurance provider for our high-risk drivers was Pafco, with Coachman following in as the runner-up with rates just 2% more expensive.  

Rankings

The auto insurance world is divided into regular market auto insurers that sell coverage to most drivers and high-risk market insurers that sell insurance to those who may have unfavourable driving records or spotty payment histories. High-risk insurers tend to sell their coverage for higher premiums, so to make things fair in our comparisons we’ve separate rankings for both carrier types.  

Table 1. Best regular market insurers for female drivers in 2024 

  1. Commonwell 
  1. CAA 
  1. Intact 
  1. SGI 
  1. Wawanesa 
  1. Economical 
  1. Zenith 
  1. Aviva 
  1. Pembridge 
  1. Travelers 

Table 2. Best high-risk market insurers for female drivers in 2024 

  1. Pafco 
  1. Coachman 
  1. JEVCO 
  1. Echelon 

Meet our drivers

To provide you with an idea of the type of rates that women in Ontario might expect from different insurers, we’ve compiled a list of eight (fictional) female driver profiles that vary by the status of their relationship (married or single), age, location, driving record, and vehicle they own. The drivers we used are fictional, but the prices listed in the table below are a representation of what someone with similar attributes might pay for their auto insurance. 

To ensure that the only variables changing was the age, marital status, vehicle, location, and driving record of the individuals, we kept coverages, deductibles, policy limits, and discounts the same. 

Here are our drivers: 

  • Isla, 23, single, Aurora (L4G), clean record 
    • Drives a 2019 NISSAN SENTRA S FWD  
  • Naomi, 37, married, London (N6B), speeding ticket in 2021 
    • Drives a 2016 MAZDA CX-5 GS AWD 
  • Georgia, 42, single, St. Catharine’s (L2R0), speeding tickets in 2019 & 2022 
    • Drives a 2017 VOLKSWAGEN GOLF SPORTWAGEN 
  • Freya, 19, single, Belleville (K8N), clean record 
    • Drives a 2015 FORD ESCAPE SE AWD 
  • Camille, 60, married, Mississauga (L5B), at-fault claim in 2020 
    • Drives a 2021 JEEP CHEROKEE SPORT 4WD 
  • Blake, 32, married, Woolwich (N3B), clean record 
    • Drives a 2018 FORD FOCUS SE HATCHBACK 
  • Sloane, 39, single, North Bay (P1B), two speeding tickets in 2022, at-fault claim in 2023 
    • Drives a 2020 BMW 3-SERIES 330i xDRIVE SEDAN AWD 
  • Olivia, 51, married, Thunder Bay (P7E), at-fault claim in 2021, distracted driving in 2024 
    • Drives a 2016 FORD F-150 XLT SUPERCREW 4WD

Quote comparisons

 
Table 1. Insurance rates compared for females in Ontario1
Insurance Company Isla Naomi Georgia Freya Camille Blake Reg Avg. Sloane Olivia High Risk Avg.
Aviva $3,698 $4,994 $2,253 $4,327 $2,325 $2.437 $3,339
CAA $5,023 $1,857 $1,535 $4.491 $1,895 $2,021 $2,803
Commonwell $3,870 $1,842 $1,967 $3,464 $2,179 $1,714 $2,506
Economical $4,007 $2,759 $2,307 $3,570 $2,721 $1,933 $3,174
Intact $3,672 $2,759 $1,933 $5,910 $3,463 $2,234 $3,281
Pembridge $4,304 $3,588 $3,414 $4,221 $3,408 $2,254 $3,531
SGI $4,601 $2,591 $1,777 $3,605 $2,790 $2,148 $2,918
Travelers $6,552 $5,160 $3,372 $3,900 $5,196 $3,348 $4,588
Wawanesa $3,526 $2,848 $2,385 $5,206 $2,532 $1,946 $3,073
Coachman $8,090 $4,322 $6,206
Echelon $9,390 $5,177 $7,283
JEVCO $8,543 $3,977 $6,260
Pafco $7,643 $4,512 $6,077
1Data source: Mitch auto insurance quoter

These rates may fluctuate over time

In our list of best insurance companies for female drivers in 2023, the results were somewhat different. This is partly because we’ve used different profiles. However, this is also because no one insurance company will remain the “most affordable” option permanently. Insurers keep a close and frequent watch on the cost of their claims and will compare them to the revenue they generate from premiums. They want to ensure that the premiums they collect are sufficient in covering claims, plus a small amount leftover for profit. 

Insurers offering the most competitive rates for female drivers tend to attract more customers based on affordability. This can prompt other companies to adjust their prices to stay competitive. However, if claim costs and frequency increase for female drivers, insurers with lower rates may need to raise prices to maintain profitability and cover expenses adequately. 

Get the best insurance rates with Mitch

We can’t pinpoint the perfect auto insurance company for you as a female driver without understanding your specific needs. However, we’re committed to helping you discover the most competitive rates consistently. Reach out to a broker at Mitch Insurance. We collaborate with over 70 of Canada’s leading insurers and are dedicated to finding you excellent coverage at an affordable price. Contact us now for a complimentary quote with no strings attached. 

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

Looking out for insurance fraud.

Spotting auto insurance fraud

March is Fraud Prevention Month, an annual campaign that aims to identify, prevent, and report fraud.  Insurance fraud is a huge issue across Canada and costs policyholders over $1 billion a year in added premiums. Plus, it puts more strain on our health care, emergency service, and court systems. When one person cheats, we all end up paying.  

Recognizing the different types of insurance fraud, what to do if you suspect fraud, and how to prevent fraud are crucial to avoid becoming an unwitting victim.  

What are the five most common types of insurance fraud?

Insurance fraud entails the intentional misuse of insurance coverage or its applications to achieve a favourable outcome. This often involves filing an exaggerated or false claim or deceiving your insurer in another way. In short, insurance fraud exploits an insurance contract rather than protecting the insured. 

Here are the five most common types of auto insurance fraud: 

  • Staged collisions, where drivers intentionally cause crashes with unsuspecting drivers (and usually make it seem as if the innocent driver is the one at-fault) 
  • False information on policies, where someone misleads their insurer by providing false info, such as the make/model of vehicle, address, etc. 
  • Automotive repair and towing companies, who overbill insurers to drive up costs.  
  • Healthcare clinics, which have you sign blank accident benefits forms and charge insurers for services that were never provided. 
  • Stolen vehicles with false VINs, that are sold to unsuspecting drivers. 

Identifying fraud: Opportunistic vs premeditated

Auto insurance fraud can be broken down into two different categories: opportunistic and premeditated. These are defined as follows: 

Opportunistic  

Following a legitimate loss, a policyholder seizes the opportunity to make an exaggerated claim to receive an unwarranted insurance payment. Some examples of this are: 

  • Including pre-collision vehicle damage in an auto insurance claim
  • Inflicting additional damage to a vehicle post-collision
  • Misrepresenting what happened so uninsured losses can be claimed
  • Making a claim for property that wasn’t stolen during a legitimate break-in
  • Lying about the condition, value, or mileage of a vehicle that was stolen
  • Exaggerating injuries following a collision:
    • Faking lingering injuries for extended recovery time
    • Accepting “free” healthcare treatment for injuries unrelated to a collision or that are considered not medically necessary
    • Encouraging others, such as drivers involved in a collision, to participate in fraud
    • Healthcare practitioners exaggerating a patient’s injuries to increase the billed amount for treatment, assessments, and assistive devices

Premeditated

Premeditated fraud involves carrying out intentional, deliberate actions to make a claim for an insured loss event. Premeditated fraud not only raises auto insurance rates for everyone, but it can involve severe bodily injury or even loss of life to unsuspecting victims. Examples of premeditated fraud include:

  • Submitting claims for fake losses
  • Plotting out vehicle collisions with unsuspecting drivers, or with other (consenting) fraudsters. Examples of staged collisions include:
    • Jump ins, when someone who isn’t a participant in the collision makes an injury claim against you with the hopes to get a settlement from your insurance
    • Drive downs, when a driver in a parking lot waves you out of a spot and then plows in to you to make it seem like you weren’t looking when pulling out
    • Swoop and squats, when a driver bolts in front of another to cause a rear-end collision
  • Burning vehicles
  • Purchasing fake insurance cards (or pink slips, as they’re also known)
  • Providing false information to avoid paying premiums

How does fraud affect other drivers?

Over 74% of Canadians are aware that insurance fraud impacts their insurance premiums, showing how much this crime has grown in frequency and severity.

If you didn’t already know, yes, insurance fraud can result in higher taxes and greatly increase your insurance costs. Consider this: who ends up paying for the additional legal bills if an insurance fraud case ends up in court? Whose premiums go into the overall pool of funds used to pay out claims? Whose taxes help pay for police investigations of collisions?

Beyond costs, insurance fraud can also cause:

  • A strain on emergency services and law enforcement, as fewer police are available to respond to legitimate emergencies and crimes
  • Additional costs for policing services, which may result in higher taxes or service cuts
  • Additional costs for health care services which may result in higher taxes or service cuts
  • Longer wait times for diagnostic tools and X-rays as our healthcare system is clogged up with falsified injuries from auto fraud cases
  • Courts are delayed by insurance fraud causes, so justice can be slowed for legitimate cases and crimes
  • The justice system is faced with additional costs, which can result in higher taxes or service cuts

Prevention: Tips for avoiding fraud

Given the current economic landscape, it’s more important than ever for all Canadians to remain vigilant and take the necessary steps to protect themselves against fraud. Here at Mitch, we recommend the following to help prevent fraud if you are involved in a collision:

  • Always contact your insurer first if a third-party tries to push you towards an unknown automotive repair shop, legal representative, or health professional
  • Only see medical and legal professionals that you trust or are recommended by individuals that you trust/know
    • Be aware of what your medical benefits are and what is covered
    • Contact legal or medical licensing regulators in your province to ensure that the service provider you are in contact with is licensed
    • Keep records of all your medical appointments, including dates and locations as well as names of practitioners, diagnoses and services, and records of medicine/supplies, or treatment that was provided
  • Make sure to compare your records against the statements your insurer provides to ensure all bills are accurate and no goods/services are included that you did not receive. Advocate for yourself if something seems amiss
  • Avoid signing blank insurance claim forms
  • Finally, be aware of what your final settlement includes

You can help prevent insurance fraud

While law enforcement does their best to prevent insurance fraud, everyone can help make a huge difference by reporting fraud if they’ve witnessed or have information about a potential crime.

Follow these steps to do your part in preventing insurance fraud:

Ways to help prevent fraud.
  • Chat with your insurance representative following a collision
  • Call Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS or file a report with local police
  • Make an anonymous call 24/7 to 1-877-IBC-TIPS
  • Notify the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre
  • Consider reaching out to consult with legal counsel

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

Woman on a roadtrip.

The best car insurance companies in Ontario for 2024

In today’s cost of living crisis, saving money where possible is essential. Insurance is a mandatory purchase, but it doesn’t have to break the bank. To save money on your insurance, you’ll want to work with the best auto insurance company. But who’s the best of the best?

Below is a breakdown of the best car insurance companies in Ontario, including what they offer, how they rank by coverage options, price, and more.

Logos of the insurance companies listed in the table below.
  1. How do you choose the “best” auto insurer?
  2. Beyond rates: What makes an auto insurance company the right choice?
    1. Customer service studies
    2. Size of insurance company
    3. Online insurance reviews
  3. Ontario auto insurance companies compared
  4. Who is the best auto insurance company in Ontario for 2024?
  5. Best auto insurance companies by demographic
    1. Female drivers under 25
    2. Female drivers over 25
    3. Male drivers under 25
    4. Male drivers over 25
    5. Senior drivers (over 65)
  6. Different companies may specialize in different types of drivers
    1. Regular (standard) market auto insurance companies
    2. High-risk auto insurance companies
    3. Specialty insurance companies
    4. Motorcycle insurance companies
    5. Ridesharing vehicle insurance companies
    6. Business vehicle insurance companies
    7. Farm vehicle insurance companies

How do you choose the “best” auto insurer?

There are more than 80 insurance companies in Ontario that sell auto insurance. Each insurance company has its own “offering,” and certain insurers only offer niche auto insurance (such as high-risk, right-hand drive, or classic car insurance).

When you want the best, you need to know what it means to be the “best.” The insurer you choose should be able to:

  • Meet your (insurance) needs
  • Offer budget-friendly rates
  • Provide excellent customer and claims service

Beyond rates: What makes an auto insurance company the right choice?

While an insurance broker’s duty is to help find you great rates, they can also help partner you with an insurer who will find you the best coverage fit. This goes beyond price. There are other ways to rank auto insurance companies beyond their price. Keep the following in mind:

1. Customer service studies

J.D. Power, a software, consumer intelligence, and data analytics company, conducts their own customer satisfaction surveys every year for auto insurance companies. While their rankings may only serve as a general guideline, it’s good to take note of common trends. Note that J.D. Power ratings do have their own limitations, such as:

  • Their surveys are only conducted using a very small sample size (minimum of 100 respondents). Given Ontario is as large as it is, sample sizes would need to be at least 1,000 to be reliable.
  • J.D. Power provides detailed results in exchange for a fee, so surveys are not intended for everyday consumers.
  • J.D. Power uses virtual panels to collect data, which tend to be less reliable than other means.
  • J.D. Power currently only has ratings for 13 of the 80+ car insurance companies in Ontario.

2. Size of insurance company

This is a factor that too few policyholders know about, but it’s important. When insurance companies are smaller, the funds that they have to payout claims also tends to be smaller. The risk that the insurance company may not have enough money to pay out all claims is greater. Larger companies tend to have a more evenly spread risk, and have also likely purchased reinsurance, so there’s less risk for the insured. This, of course, isn’t always an exact science – and sometimes the smaller guys will meet your needs even better than the big guys!

3. Online insurance reviews

While reviews are not solely about what drivers should go off, they can be an indicator of the kind of service you might expect from an insurance company. They can be skewed because:

  • Many customers will only leave a review after a bad experience
  • The larger the company, the more customers they have – and the worse reviews they’ll get
  • Insurance is complicated, and oftentimes reviews are based off people’s limited knowledge of how different coverages function

The best you can take away from online reviews is how insurance companies “argue” over what’s covered when a claim is filed and how easy they are to contact. Reviews may be able to show how well (or poorly) an insurance company fares for these aspects.

Ontario auto insurance companies compared

There’s no definitive way to say which auto insurance company is the best. We’ve created the table below to show the differences between different auto insurers. Note that we can only access pricing information from the auto insurers that we partner with:

 
Table 1. Ontario auto insurance companies compared
Insurance Company Type of Insurance Sold How to Buy1 J.D. Power Rating2 Google Rating3 Size (by premiums)
AIG Canada Business Broker   1.8 / 5
(46)
Small
Allstate Insurance Co. of Canada Regular, motorcycle Agent, Direct 762/1000 3.9 / 5
(2,446)
Medium
Aviva Canada Regular, motorcycle, specialty, business, ride-sharing Broker 751/1000 4.1 / 5
(3,361)
Large
Belairdirect Regular, ride-sharing Broker 779/1000 4.2 / 5
(6,174)
Large
Beazely Canada Business Broker   5 / 5
(1)
Small
CAA Insurance Regular Broker   4.2 / 5
(6,414)
Medium
Travelers Essential Regular Broker 2.5 / 5
(234)
Small
Chubb Insurance Co. of Canada Business Broker   2.6 / 5
(116)
Small
Coachman Insurance Co. High-Risk Broker   2.4 / 5
(32)
Small
Commonwell Mutual Insurance Group Regular, business Broker   3.0 / 5
(101)
Small
The Co-operators Insurance Regular, business Direct 809/1000 4.3 / 5
(4,420)
Large
Coseco Insurance Regular Broker   2.9 / 5
(143)
Small
CUMIS Regular Broker   3.6 / 5
(18)
Small
Desjardins Insurance Regular, motorcycle Agent, Direct 748/1000 4.8 / 5
(16,859)
Large
Dufferin Mutual Insurance Co. Regular, business Broker   2.7 / 5
(11)
Small
Echelon Insurance Co. High-Risk, motorcycle, specialty Broker   1.9 / 702
(75)
Medium
Economical Insurance Regular, High-risk, business Broker 793/1000 2.1 / 5
(694)
Large
Facility Association High-Risk, motorcycle, specialty Broker   1.9 / 5
(9)
Medium
Federated Insurance Regular, business Broker   4.3 / 5
(44)
Small
Gore Mutual Insurance Co. Regular, business Broker   2.5 / 5
(431)
Medium
Grenville Mutual Insurance Co. Regular Broker   3.7 / 5
(32)
Small
The Guarantee Co. Regular Broker   2.2 / 5
(14)
Small
Hagerty Specialty Broker   4.6 / 5
(315)
Small
Halwell Mutual Insurance Co. Business Broker   3.8 / 5
(12)
Small
Heartland Farm Mutual Inc Regular Broker   3.0 / 5
(72)
Small
HTM Insurance Co. Business Broker   4.3 / 5
(16)
Small
Intact Insurance Regular, motorcycle, specialty, business, ride-sharing Broker 768/1000 3.3 / 5
(1,630)
Large
Jevco Insurance High-Risk Broker   2.6 / 5
(184)
Medium
Novex Insurance Co. Regular Broker   1.3 / 13
(6)
Small
Northbridge Insurance Regular, business Broker   3.7 / 5
(292)
Medium
Optimum General Insurance Regular Broker   3.0 / 5
(18)
Small
Pafco Insurance High-Risk Broker   1.8 / 5
(178)
Medium
Peel Mutual Insurance Co. Regular, business Broker   2.7 / 5
(40)
Small
Pembridge Insurance Co. Regular, motorcycle Broker   1.7 / 5
(754)
Medium
The Personal Regular, motorcycle Broker 798/1000 3.1 / 5
(825)
Small
Portage Mutual Insurance Regular, business Broker   3.4 / 5
(14)
Small
RBC Insurance Regular Direct 794/1000 3.5 / 5
(562)
Medium
RSA Canada Regular, motorcycle, business Broker   2.8 / 5
(121)
Medium
Scottish & York Regular Broker   1 / 5
(1)
Small
Security National Regular Direct   Large
SGI Canada Regular Broker   3.2 / 5
(317)
Small
Sonnet Insurance Regular Direct   Large
TD General Insurance Regular, motorcycle Direct 763/1000 3.6 / 5
(2,273)
Large
Traders General Insurance Co. Regular Broker   Small
Travelers Canada Regular, motorcycle, specialty, business Broker 779/1000 2.4 / 5
(216)
Medium
Trillium Mutual Insurance Co. Regular, business Broker   3.3 / 5
(29)
Small
Trushield Insurance Regular, business Broker   4.4 / 5
(292)
Small
Unica Insurance Regular, business Broker   4.1 / 5
(188)
Small
Unifund Assurance Regular Broker   Small
Onlia Insurance (Onlia) Regular Agent   3.3 / 5
(484)
Small
Wawanesa Insurance Regular, business Broker 751/1000 2.0 / 5
(414)
Medium
Western Assurance Regular Broker   2.2 / 5
(19)
Small
Zenith Insurance Co. Regular, motorcycle Broker   1.4 / 5
(19)
Small
Zurich Canada Business Broker   4.3 / 5
(19)
Small
1Agents sell through a network of agents that only sell their products. Brokers sell through independent brokers, who also offer quotes from other insurance companies. Direct means they sell directly to the public, usually online or by phone; 2Overall customer satisfaction index ranking, Ontario region – J.D. Power 2019 Canada Auto Insurance Satisfaction Study. (Note: J.D. Power Ratings are only available for companies that got a minimum of 100 responses from the consumer survey); 3Average Google rating for all Ontario locations as of February 2024.

Who is the best auto insurance company in Ontario for 2024?

There is no single best auto insurance company in Ontario that works for everyone, as everybody’s personal insurance needs are just that: personal. What works for Bob and Jerry down the road may not work for you, as your driving habits may be different, your driving experience, the cars you drive, etc. The table below shows pricing comparisons between some of our partners for different demographics:

 
Table 2. Average Ontario auto insurance rates for male, female, and senior drivers1
Insurance company Rates for females (over 25) Rates for females (under 25)2 Rates for males (over 25) Rates for males (under 25)
Aviva $3,537 $4,296 $3,315 $4,279
CAA $2,758 $4,990 $2,758 $6,078
Economical $3,461 $4,695 $3,525 $4,775
Intact $3,348 $3,686 $3,051 $3,629
Pembridge $3,924 $4,658 $3,783 $4,345
SGI Canada $3,083 $3,969 $3,072 $3,676
Travelers $4,812 $6,276 $4,916 $6,372
Wawanesa $2,899 $3,577 $3,192 $3,893
1Data source: Mitch auto insurance quoter (ranked by price in parentheses) ;2Rates for younger females are typically lower than those for young males. Quotes shown are higher because of the specific driver profiles chosen.

Get an auto insurance quote in minutes.

Best auto insurance companies by demographic

As different insurance companies tend to go after different demographics, no one company offers the best, most affordable rates for every driver. If you’re a female under 30, you might not enjoy the same rates as your neighbour, Derek, who’s 55.

The only way to find your best rate is to get a quote from as many different companies as possible. If you contact a direct insurer or an insurance agent, you will only get the price for that one insurance company. Also, note that online quotes are notoriously inaccurate. You won’t have a really good idea of actual price unless you call.

As different insurance companies tend to go after different demographics, no one company offers the best, most affordable rates for every driver. If you’re a female under 30, you might not enjoy the same rates as your neighbour, Derek, who’s 55.

How do you tell which insurance company is best for your needs? Get a different quote from as many insurance companies as possible. You can technically do this by calling around to the individual insurers, but this is a long, tedious process, and online quotes are usually inaccurate.

Your best bet is to go through an insurance broker, specifically one that works with plenty of different insurance companies. Mitch is trusted by thousands of policyholders because it represents more than 70 different insurers, where some brokers will only work with a few.

Here’s a breakdown of what you might expect from different insurers based on gender/age:

To give you an idea of what you can expect from different insurers based on your gender and age, we ran a variety of quotes in our online auto insurance quoter, and found the following:

Female drivers under 25:

  • Wawanesa has the best rates for female drivers under 25.
  • Different female drivers with different demographics may get their best rates for different insurers. Of all the companies we ran, Wawanesa, SGI, and Intact had the best rates.

Read more: The best insurance companies for younger drivers in Ontario in 2023

Female drivers over 25:

  • CAA has the best rates for female drivers over 25.
  • Again, rates will differ depending on the female driver. While CAA had the lowest rates on average for our female driver, Wawanesa and SGI were close contenders.

Read more: The best insurance companies for female drivers in Ontario in 2024 

Male drivers under 25:

  • Intact has the best rates for male drivers under 25.
  • Rates will differ by more than just your gender and age. Intact had the most affordable rates for men in this demographic but SGI and Wawanesa weren’t far behind.

Read more: The best insurance companies for younger drivers in Ontario in 2023

Male drivers over 25

  • CAA has the best rates for male drivers over 25.
  • Intact, SGI, and Wawanesa were also some of the top companies for male drivers over 25.

Read more: The best insurance companies for male drivers in Ontario in 2024

Senior drivers (over 65)

  • After running a few quotes to compare prices for male and female drivers over 65, we found that the most affordable company for men and women over 65 was CAA. Aviva, Intact, and SGI also offered good rates.

Read more: The best insurance companies for older drivers in Ontario in 2023

Different companies may specialize in different types of drivers

All drivers with a valid Ontario license are entitled to fair access to insurance. Different insurers will specialize in different types of “risk,” meaning some companies may offer insurance to drivers who would otherwise have a difficult time getting insured through the regular market. In the chart above, we included which companies are open to business in different categories. Here’s a breakdown of those different categories:

1. Regular (standard) market auto insurance companies

Most drivers in Ontario are insured through what is known as the standard market. This means that the companies who offer “standard” insurance will offer it to low or medium-risk drivers, so drivers who don’t use their cars for business usage, aren’t right-hand drive, don’t have modifications, or who don’t have more than three tickets/at-fault accidents on their record.

2. High-risk auto insurance companies

High-risk auto insurance, also called nonstandard auto insurance, is offered by companies who specialize in insurance for drivers whose risk profile would otherwise be uninsurable by standard market companies. This is usually due to serious driving convictions, at-fault accidents, or having been cancelled due to a history of non-payment.

3. Specialty insurance companies

Some insurance companies specialize in offering insurance to what are known as non-standard vehicles, which are often right-hand drive, classic/collector vehicles, or vehicles that have been heavily modified.

4. Motorcycle insurance companies

In Ontario, motorcycle insurance tends to rack higher than car insurance on average as accidents can involve severe injuries, and may include the potential for long-term disability. Motorcycle insurance, as a result, can be riskier – even with more experienced drivers.

Few insurers will insure drivers under 25 or who have less than 5 years of riding experience. In this case, they may need to obtain coverage through Facility Association as their only option.

5. Ridesharing vehicle insurance companies

If you use your personal vehicle for ridesharing companies such as Lyft or Uber, and you transport either food or passengers, then many insurers may not agree to work with you, and you’ll have to acquire specialized insurance through a rideshare insurer. This tends to be more expensive than standard auto insurance.

6. Business vehicle insurance companies

Using a car for business purposes, such as owning a vehicle with business branding, hauling goods, tools, or delivering passengers, calls for commercial auto insurance. Many auto insurers specialize in insuring business vehicles.

7. Farm vehicle insurance companies

There are quite a few options for farmers wanting to insure their farm-use vehicles, with over 40 farm mutuals operating in Ontario. Note a few of these mutuals only operate in their immediate geographic region. Some business vehicle insurers will also cover farm vehicles as well.

Different companies may specialize in different types of drivers

While it can be tough to choose a car insurance company that’s right for you, Mitch can help. We partner with many of Canada’s top auto insurance providers, so we’re confident we can help you find a company that fits the bill and for a great rate, too.

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

Thinking about car insurance coverage.

What to consider before you remove DC-PD coverage from your policy

On January 1, 2024, Ontario changed direct compensation-property damage (DC-PD) to optional coverage, allowing drivers to sign a form (called OPCF 49) to remove it from their policy. 

DC-PD was mandatory as part of Ontario’s no-fault auto insurance system introduced in 1990. Making it optional was done to allow consumers more control over their coverage and provide an option to reduce costs. However, electing to remove DC-PD can prove more harm than good. Here’s why. 

How does DC-PD work?

The cost of having DC-PD in your insurance policy varies by the vehicle, your demographics, how long you’ve been licensed, where you live, etc., but usually it averages between $400-$1,000/year. For most people, the biggest reason for opting out of DC–PD is to save this amount – but many may end up paying more than if they had kept DC–PD in their policy. 

DC-PD covers you if you’re involved in an accident with another driver where you were either only partially at-fault or not at-fault. For example, someone rear-ended you at a red light. DC-PD would trigger and help cover: 

What's covered in DC-PD outlined below.
Fig. 1. What DC-PC can help cover
  • Repair costs for your vehicle 
  • Replacement costs for contents inside your vehicle 
  • Loss of use of your vehicle 
  • Towing and storage fees 

If you sign OPCF 49 to remove DC-PD, you would not have coverage for any of these things in a not at-fault accident. Drivers may be severely financially impacted by vehicle damage if they’re hit by another driver or involved in a partially at-fault accident without this coverage.  

What are the drawbacks of removing DC-PD?

For most drivers, we recommend not signing OPCF 49, especially if you want to cut costs. The endorsement may provide you with more choice, but it puts a lot of financial onus on you if you’re involved in a traffic collision – even one where you’re not at-fault.  

Here are some of the main drawbacks of removing DC-PD from your policy:  

Paying out-of-pocket

Without DC-PD coverage, you’d be left arranging and paying for the costs to repair your own vehicle, replace the contents left inside the vehicle, rent a car, and cover any additional fees pertaining to storage and towing. 

Denied claims

As signing OPCF 49 removes DC-PD from your policy, you’re likelier to have not at-fault claims rejected as your policy will no longer meet your coverage needs.  

Lengthy repair times

The length of time it takes to repair vehicles is longer nowadays because of chip shortages and supply chain issues. If you’re in an accident, you may need to find a temporary replacement for your car to get to work or do other daily tasks. DC-PD contains coverage for loss of use, but if you’ve removed it from your policy by signing OPCF 49, the price of a rental car is your own responsibility. According to Enterprise, Ontario currently has the longest average billed days (19.5) for rental vehicles where the driver is awaiting repairs. For rentals associated with total losses, the number is a bit higher at 24 days (about 3 and a half weeks) average. 

This can rack up quickly in cost, especially when you consider that an Enterprise mid-sized SUV averages out to around $48.24 plus HST per day, and a pick-up truck will run about $45.74 plus HST. Non-Enterprise vehicle rentals will typically exceed $65/day. 

Does signing OPCF 49 lower your insurance costs?

Yes, signing OPCF 49 and removing DC-PD may allow you to lower your premium by between 5% and 10%. But there’s more to it than that. Without DC-PD, you greatly risk being underinsured, and if money is already tight, OPCF 49 can put you in a worse situation than you would have been in had you not opted out of the coverage.  

Talk with an insurance broker before electing to include OPCF 49 and opting out of DC-PD coverage. 

Alternatives to removing DC-PD coverage from your auto insurance

We’re living in a cost-of-living crisis, and so it’s no wonder people are tempted by this new offering. Saving a few hundred dollars a year can be a huge opportunity for many but removing DC-PD may cost you more than you’d end up saving if you need to repair or replace your vehicle after a not at-fault accident. Here’s some alternative suggestions to removing DC-PD coverage from your auto insurance to help you save money: 

Raise your DC-PD deductible 

One alternative to removing DC-PD coverage altogether is to raise your deductible on it. DC-PD coverage automatically comes with no deductible, meaning in a not at-fault collision you’d pay nothing for the repairs to your car, but you can elect to raise that amount. Doing so will lower your rates, but it will also mean you’ll be responsible for a certain amount out-of-pocket if you’re involved in an accident. Choose this option with care. 

Ask about bundling your home and auto insurance 

Bundling your insurance is one of the easiest ways to save money on your coverage; in fact, what you save may equal or even exceed what you’d save by dropping DC-PD. If you have a home or renters policy, you can save hundreds of dollars on your auto insurance by insuring them through the same provider. Talk with one of our insurance brokers for more information about this option. 

Try usage-based insurance 

Usage-based insurance is a program through which you agree to have your driving behaviours tracked. Good driving behaviour can result in savings, and many programs will offer you an initial 5%-10% discount for just signing up. Some programs can save you up to 30% on your insurance. 

It’s important to look at all your options before opting out of DC-PD 

If you’re considering OPCF 49 to remove DC-PD from your policy, give us a call. Mitch works with over 70 of Canada’s top insurers and can help find you an affordable alternative without needing to sacrifice much-needed coverage. 

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

Driver driving behind a car.

How to handle insurance claims with unknown parties

Getting into an accident is no fun, but it can be especially confusing on how to proceed with a claim if the other driver has fled the scene or is unable to be identified.

For example, imagine you’re hit by a driver who merges into your lane without looking. When the police arrive, they prevent you from interacting with the other driver (which is common to prevent arguments from escalating) and you are left unsure on how to proceed with your insurance claim.

Here’s some clarification on making claims with unidentified parties, whether it’s a hit-and-run or otherwise.

Navigating the insurance process

Accidents where you’re unable to obtain information at the scene of a traffic collision (hit-and-runs are a good example), can be complicated when it comes to filing an insurance claim. You can end up in a situation where even though you don’t believe you’re at fault for an incident, you’re left waiting for the adjuster to verify insurance for the other party. Even if the other driver is present, police sometimes want to avoid drivers from interacting to reduce the risk of arguments or disagreements.

This gets especially tricky and confusing if the other driver fled the scene. You may not know what to do or who to talk to next. Filing a claim is doubly confusing. In instances like these, or even instances where you’re unable to speak to the other driver who is present, we recommend asking the police for a copy of the accident report. Having your insurance company do this for you can take weeks, which can delay your settlement, and can leave you uncertain as to whether you’re responsible for your deductible or how much coverage you have (if any at all).

Am I covered?

Here are the different coverages that may apply in the event of an accident, such as where you’re unable to identify the other driver or are involved in a hit-and-run:

Uninsured motorist coverage

Uninsured motorist coverage will cover you if the other driver ends up being later identified and they have insufficient or no insurance. This coverage:

  • Either has no deductible or a lower deductible than collision/comprehensive
  • Can help pay for medical bills and property damage
  • Has variable coverage limits depending on what you choose

Unfortunately, uninsured motorist coverage won’t cover you for hit-and-runs where the other party ends up never being identified.

Direct compensation – property damage coverage (DC-PD)

DC-PD coverage is optional in Ontario, so you’ll only this coverage if you elected not to remove it from your policy. DC-PD coverage:

  • Covers damages to your vehicle due to a not at-fault collision
  • Triggers as long as all the vehicles in the collision are insured
  • Is covered through your own insurance provider

Based on the parameters of DC-PD, you won’t be covered for hit-and-runs and may only be covered if the other driver is identified and insured. This is why we recommend getting a copy of the police report at the scene or at the nearest police station.

Collision coverage

In the unfortunate circumstances where you’re the victim of a hit-and-run and the other party is unable to be identified at all, you may have coverage under your collision insurance. As collision insurance is optional, electing not to purchase it will leave you having to pay for the accident out-of-pocket. Collision insurance can cover your car for physical damages even if the other driver is never identified. It will also insure you for physical damages to your vehicle if you caused an accident or if you hit a stationary object.

In the event of an incident where you’re unable to speak to the other party or they haven’t been identified, knowing whether you’re covered or not can be invaluable. We advise getting a copy of your police report as soon as possible and getting in touch with your insurer to start the claims process. During this time, your broker can answer any questions or concerns you might have.

Understanding legal obligations for hit-and-runs

In Ontario, you are required to report hit-and-run incidents to the police. It’s crucial both for your insurance claim and for the pursuit of justice. Based on the Provincial Offences Act, Ontario hit-and-run drivers can be charged for their participation in a collision up to six months after it has occurred. Even if the situation had no witnesses, something like dashcam footage could be vital evidence in investigations.

Documenting the scene

Having as much documentation of the incident as possible is crucial, especially if you end up being the victim of a hit-and-run. Take photos and videos of your vehicle and the damages. Ask witnesses for statements (if present) and make sure to get their contact information.

Even the most trivial of details – such as a scrap of yellow metal on the ground from the fleeing vehicle – could prove useful later in identifying the perpetrator. Imagine your car was hit by another vehicle in a public parking lot. Nearby surveillance cameras from a grocery store capture the event, which law enforcement can then use to trace the vehicle involved and identify the driver.

While filing a claim where you’re unable to interact with the other party can be confusing, following the appropriate steps and reporting the incident to the relevant authorities can help to navigate the claims process more effectively. Prompt action is always key. Contact Mitch if you have further questions.

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

Parked cars in a parking lot.

Your car’s been hit in a parking lot. What now?

Imagine you’re going about your daily errands and just when you’re getting into your car after buying groceries, someone reverses into you.

Anytime you’re involved in an automobile accident, knowing what next steps to take can be invaluable. Here’s what to do if you’re involved in a parking lot accident.

Here’s what you need to know about parking lot accidents in Ontario

Parking lot accidents are a lot more common than you might think. Roughly one in five traffic collisions that occur in Canada take place in parking lots, and despite the low speeds they can often result in serious injuries and property damage.

What’s more is that parking lot accidents, like any car accident, can affect your auto insurance. For this reason, many parking lot accidents go unreported, and hit-and-runs are common.

It’s a popular misconception that parking lot accidents should be treated differently than any accident on public roads, especially those that take place in residential lots. This is not true, and like all car accidents, if the estimated damage exceeds $2,000 or someone is injured, you’ll need to call the police and file an accident report.

Types of parking lot accidents

While it’s commonly assumed that both drivers are deemed equally at fault in most parking lot accidents, that’s not always true. Some of the most common types of parking lot accidents include:

  • Vehicles competing for a spot collide. Usually this will result in near 50-50 fault, as both drivers will have some kind of responsibility for the collision.
  • Vehicles hitting a stationary object. In these situations, the driver hitting the object will be assigned 100% fault.
  • Vehicles hitting another vehicle that’s stationary. These are very common incidents, usually where the moving vehicle is backing out or pulling into a space.
  • Vehicles backing up simultaneously. This may result in 50-50 fault for both drivers.
  • Vehicles hitting cyclists or pedestrians. Parking lot spaces can be quite condensed, so it can be difficult to spot pedestrians and cyclists. Depending on the situation, the driver may be deemed at-fault.
  • Vehicle rear ends another that’s stopped. Even though you may not be moving fast, there’s a lot of things to pay attention to while driving in a parking lot – and distraction may cause you to collide with another vehicle that’s stopped ahead of you. Usually, these collisions will result in the driver doing the rear-ending being assigned all or majority fault.

Insurance companies are responsible for determining fault. Each company has a team of adjusters who analyze the evidence, review the details of the accident, and apply Ontario’s “Fault Determination Rules” (which outlines specific guidelines for determining faults) to decide.

What to do following a parking lot accident

Follow these steps following a parking lot accident, as you would with any other traffic collision:

Steps to take in a parking lot accident.
Fig 1. Steps to take following a car accident in a parking lot
  • If anyone was inside your vehicle at the time of the accident, check for injuries
  • If possible, move your vehicle out of the way of traffic and put on your hazard lights
  • Check to see if the other driver is alright and no one in their car is hurt
  • Exchange information (insurance, license information, registration, etc.)
  • If the estimated damage exceeds $2,000, report the accident
  • If required, take your vehicle to the nearest collision reporting center
  • Call your broker or your insurer

Going the “insurance route”

If you decide to file a claim after a parking lot accident, you’ll have to contact your insurer. Make sure to give them as much information as possible, including providing any photographs, documented witness statements, etc. With parking lot incidents, there’s the chance you could scrounge up security footage of the collision – which can go a long way, especially if the other driver was unable to be identified.

Speaking of unidentified drivers, what happens in the event of a hit-and-run where either the other party takes off or you come outside to see your car has been hit with no other driver in sight? Unfortunately, uninsured motorist coverage will only cover you if the other driver is identified (even a license plate will do) but underinsured/uninsured. To have coverage for a hit-and-run where the other driver can’t be identified, you’d have to have collision insurance.

What if your deductible is higher than the cost of the damages? Most drivers with collision insurance elect to have deductibles of $500 to $1,000, or even more in some cases. You won’t be covered if your deductible exceeds the cost of the damages.

You have a year to file a claim, but we suggest contacting your broker or insurer to get the process started as soon as possible. The quicker you get your car fixed, the sooner you can move on with your life.

Going the “non-insurance route”

In incidents where damage is very minor, which is sometimes the case with parking lot fender benders, drivers may elect to pay for damages out-of-pocket. You should still let your broker know about the accident. Why? Well, having a conversation with a broker about an accident isn’t the same as reporting to your insurer. Your broker can provide you with advice based on the scenario and then wait until you decide about what to do. If you are considering handling the matter on your own from the get-go, be sure to ask your broker not to report it to your company yet. The only time a broker has no choice but to report it is if the other party has already reported it to their company.

Paying out-of-pocket can be an option if the costs are manageable and you want to deal with them on your own. It also won’t affect your insurance premiums later if you go this route, and many at-fault drivers will choose this option assuming damage is minimal. Still, you’ll want to ensure you still get the other drivers’ information and that everything is in order. You don’t want to be given false information and have the other driver skip out, leaving you with the bill. Make sure you have their license number, insurance information, and license plate.

For further questions regarding getting hit in a parking lot, whether to file a claim, and other post-collision steps, give us a call. Our team of insurance brokers is always happy to help.

Thanks to Mitch Insurance’s Jesica Ryzynski, registered insurance broker since 1997, for her input on this post.

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

Cars driving down a highway in Toronto.

International driving experience and your insurance

Canada welcomes hundreds of thousands of new immigrants each year. As a newcomer to Canada, you can obtain auto insurance with either a valid international or provincial driver’s license. You may be aware of this already, but car insurance rates can fluctuate due to many factors and premiums for international drivers as international driving experience may be interpreted differently by local carriers.

Let’s take a deeper look at how driving experience from abroad works when it comes to your auto insurance in Canada.

Can I use the insurance I had in my home country to drive in Canada?

Some insurance policies from foreign countries will include coverage for driving in Canada, whereas others won’t. You’ll need to check with your provider to see if your policy offers you coverage while driving in Canada and if there’s any restrictions for how long you’re covered. There also may be specific coverage restrictions, and you may need to consider purchasing additional insurance from a Canadian insurer.

It’s always a good idea to familiarize yourself with what the insurance regulations are in a country you’ll be driving in (whether you’re moving there or staying for a period of time). If an accident occurs, you don’t want to learn the hard way that you weren’t adequately covered.

What if I’m just a tourist?

The same deal as above applies to tourists driving in Canada. If you’ve brought over your own vehicle, you might be able to get insurance coverage via your existing auto insurer. If your current provider doesn’t extend coverage to Canada, you’ll need to purchase a separate policy. If you’re renting a vehicle through a rental car company, they will typically offer their own form of insurance, which is usually called a “Loss Damage Waiver” or “Collision Damage Waiver”.

What is the process for getting car insurance in Canada with a foreign driver’s license?

You’ll likely be able to get car insurance in Canada even if you have a foreign driver’s license, but you could be required to take a driving test to show you are familiar with Canadian driving regulations. You may also need to prove you have some level of Canadian driving experience before you will be eligible for coverage with some insurers.

In some cases though, foreign drivers will need to have proof of their permanent residence in Canada and/or a valid provincial driver’s license.

Obtaining a driver’s license in Canada as an international driver

The process varies depending on what province you’re trying to obtain a license in, but in Alberta and Ontario it’s fairly simple.

Getting an Ontario driver’s license as an international driver

Highway sign in Ontario.

To switch your existing international driver’s license to an Ontario one, you’ll need to apply in-person at a DriveTest centre, or alternatively visit the Service Ontario Bay and College location in downtown Toronto. You can exchange your out-of-country or out-of-province license for an Ontario license if you are currently relocating from:

  • Any other province or territory in Canada
  • Canadian Armed Forces
  • U.S. States
  • Australia, Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Great Britain, the Isle of Man, Japan, South Korea, New Zealand, Northern Ireland, Republic of Ireland, Switzerland, Taiwan

You’ll need to provide proof of your past driving experience in your home country. Every new driver in Ontario must go through the graduated licensing program to learn how to drive (in a controlled environment). This program also applies to drivers with foreign experience even if they cannot prove that experience. To apply for your Ontario license, you’ll need to:

  • Pay applicable fees
  • Take a vision test
  • Bring original (valid) out-of-province or out-of-country driver’s license
  • Bring any documents supporting your driving experience in English or French
  • Bring originals of accepted identity documents with legal name and DOB
  • Fill out an application form

If you’re not from a country that can exchange your license (either because there’s no exchange agreement in place, because the license is a learner’s permit/novice-class driver’s license, or because it’s a motorcycle class driver’s license from Japan, South Korea, Germany, France, Great Britain, Austria, Isle of Man, or Republic of Ireland) you can still get credit for previous driving experience. Check out this licenses for out-of-provinces and out-of-country drivers guide.

Getting an Albertan driver’s license as an international driver

Highway sign in Alberta.

If you’re from an eligible country and hold a valid driver’s license, you can trade it in for an Alberta license by going to a registry and bringing the following:

  • Proof of your current residence in Canada
  • Proof of a valid address in Alberta
  • Your current driver’s license
  • Proof of two years of driving experience (DL extract and receipt)

If you are unable to prove at least two years of driving experience, then you will receive a Class 5-GDL until you can provide sufficient proof.

If your license isn’t from an eligible country, then you’ll need to pass a knowledge test to receive a Class 7 learner’s license, and then take the road test to receive a Class 5.

Is car insurance for foreign drivers more expensive?

Often, yes. The cost of auto insurance for foreign drivers varies based on their circumstances and their country of origin. It might cost more because their driving experience may not be considered the same way, especially if their foreign driving experience isn’t valued equally to Canadian driving experience. The reason for this is simply that rules and regulations are different depending on where you live, and insurers may see foreign drivers as less experienced in driving on Canadian roads (and therefore more inclined to be involved in collisions).

That doesn’t mean foreign drivers can’t save on their rates. Working with an insurance brokerage like Mitch unlocks unique opportunities to access things like multiple policy discounts, low mileage discounts and more. We work with over 70 top-rated Canadian insurers to find the coverage that’s right for you at the best price possible. Give us a call for a free quote today.

Looking for car insurance?

Speak with a Mitch Insurance broker today to get a quote on Ontario auto insurance.

Call now

1-800-731-2228

Read more

2024 goals notebook.

Setting personal goals for 2024 with the Mitch team

The start of a new year is a great time to set new personal goals for the months ahead. Having different accomplishments that you’re working towards achieving leads to greater happiness, fulfillment and – more often than not – some very cool and memorable experiences.

Whether it’s traveling someplace you’ve never been, learning a new skill, finishing a major project or checking things off your bucket list, we love seeing people setting and working towards goals. Here are some of the personal goals our teammates at Mitch Insurance are looking to achieve in 2024.

Angela Allison, Account Manager: My personal goal for next year is to travel! I want to see more of Canada as I’ve never been out west. There are so many interesting things to see and do in our country. I’ve only been to a few states in the US as well. In 2024, I want to visit Alberta, Nova Scotia, Delaware and Nevada.

Becky Burnett, Personal Insurance Advisor: My personal goal for 2024 is to focus on daily happiness and making memories with my kids every day instead of only looking forward to events, vacations or long weekends. I want to learn to live in the moment with my family and not take the small moments for granted.

Cheryl Thornton, Personal Insurance Advisor: I’m a true artist at heart you can often find me decorating someone else’s home, helping someone find that perfect gift, or tinkering around in my apartment to change a room to better fit my style. In 2024, I would like to finish writing my book and to start painting again on canvas, to truly explore the artist inside me while still enjoying the analytical side every day with my insurance broker role.

Ian Mewhinney, Quality Assurance Specialist: My goal for next year is to keep my New Year’s resolution. I had a streak of keeping it for four years in a row, but I’ve fallen off in recent years. In 2024, I want to stop eating potato chips. It was one of the first resolutions I kept in the past, and I’m hoping it will help me get back on track.

Jesica Ryzynski, Claims Specialist: My goal for 2024 is to take better care of my own health and well-being, so I can continue to care for those around me.

Kathryn Lebert, Solutions Specialist: I’m hoping to see at least six concerts next year, starting with a road trip in April to see Starset perform in Michigan.

Lena Perkins, Creative and UX Designer: In 2024, I want to take more art classes. I joined a printmaking class this year and loved it. It’s a great way to express my creativity and try some different mediums. I think I’ll do a pottery class next year. I also want to read more books. This year, I read 30 books. Next year, I’m aiming for 35. And I want to have a perfect downward dog form as well. Well, maybe not perfect, but I want to improve my joint mobility to reduce risk of injuries and improve my workout game. Yoga class here I come!

Lisa Indriksons, Commercial Account Manager: I moved to New Brunswick a year ago after living my whole life in Ontario, but haven’t really had a chance to explore it properly. My goal for the upcoming year is to make it to at least one provincial park for a camping trip and to try to get to all of the tourist spots around the province to check them out.

Lynda Taylor, Underwriting: Next year, I want to go camping in Revelstoke Park with my sisters and finally complete renovations on my home, which we’ve working on for the last couple of years.

Lyndsey Dewdney, Renewal Specialist: In 2024, my goal is to establish a steady exercise routine guided by my 82-year-old father-in-law, who is a seasoned personal trainer. I anticipate that the workouts might challenge our relationship at times – I’m counting on some good-natured grumbling during the sessions. Overall, I’m excited for his help in reaching my fitness goals and hope this shared experience will not only contribute to my well-being but also strengthen our relationship in a unique way.

Natalie Mullins, Personal Insurance Advisor: My goal is to keep working on my bucket-list item of visiting all of the Medieval Times in North America. I’ve been to the ones in Toronto and New Jersey, and this year I want to make it out to the one in Scottsdale, Arizona.

Shawn Despres, Head of Communications: I want to run Hamilton’s Around the Bay Race in March. I’m going to start with the 5K run and will hopefully work my way up to longer marathons. I’m a huge live music fan and next year I’d love to catch a concert at Red Rocks Amphitheatre in Colorado. It’s definitely a bucket list venue for me.

Tammy Floyd, Receptionist: I’m the type of person that very seldom takes time for myself. Next year, I want to work on taking better care of myself. It’s important for everyone to do and is good for both your mental and overall health.

Victoria Deschênes-Rivers, Underwriting: I’m hoping to do a week-long trip to the Bruce Peninsula and explore Tobermory. I’d like to visit a few other Ontario Parks campgrounds too. I’m going to push myself to participate in a few 5K runs, and to renovate our kitchen and bathrooms on a budget.

Comment below and let us know some of your personal goals for 2024. If one of your goals is to save on insurance, give us a call. Our brokers are always happy to help!


Read more

Didn’t find what you were looking for?

Check out some of our other insurance products.